Skip to content
Guardian Primary Care
Home›Resources›Article
Patient Education

AI Self-Triage Symptom Checkers (Better, Faster Healthcare Answers)

Preston Holifield, DNP, APRN, FNP-C•First published August 25, 2023•6 min read
A woman with a cold on her couch, talking with a provider on a laptop video call

It’s the start of the week and you have a bad case of the Mondays. You finally took some much needed time off for the first time this year the week prior, and you instantly feel the lack of motivation set in as your alarm sounds at 7:00am. After a little self pep-talk you finally muster the energy to take that first step out of bed and make your way to the restroom. As you are getting dressed and ready for the day you notice that you feel a little light-headed, but you don’t think much of it as it is still early and you have not yet had your morning cup of coffee. Once you are all spruced up & dressed to the T, you head to the kitchen, pour yourself a cup of coffee, and make the routine commute to work. Once you have finally arrived at your office and begin to make yourself comfortable in your office chair the workday starts to feel just a bit more doable as your morning dose of caffeine begins to do its job. That is, until you begin to notice that your pesky little nose won’t quit running. Naturally, you shrug this off too, chalking it up to allergies and continue about your day. Not too much further into the day, you begin to notice that you can’t seem to stop coughing. Come to think of it… you begin to realize your throat might be a little sore also.

“That’s it!” you say. “I am calling the Doctor.” After all, you are a busy person and you don’t have time to be dealing with sickness. “Surely the Doctor can give me something to make me feel better,” you think to yourself. The phone rings a couple of times until you are met with the voice of your local medical office’s secretary: “This is Jane Doe at Dr. Stethoscope’s office, how can I help you?” You share your story with her and she responds: “I see… I am sorry to hear that you don’t feel well. Unfortunately, Dr. Stethoscope’s next available appointment is in 3 days. I recommend you try taking some Claritin in the meantime. I will get you on the books, but please let us know if there is anything else you need us to do in the meantime, thank you!”

“Claritin?” you think to yourself. What a waste of a phone call, it’s a good thing I didn’t actually go in.

Alas, this brings us to our question today: how do I know when to go to the Doctor? Furthermore, how do I come prepared? Great questions! In this article, I will attempt to answer this question.

The first question to answer is: what is the severity of your symptoms & what might they indicate? This can be a tricky question to answer as there are many different healthcare services out there which claim to be the best, but can produce misleading information without proper background knowledge and context. For this reason, I feel that the best approach to healthcare for the majority of individuals without healthcare backgrounds and/or interests is the “KISS method” (Keep It Simple Silly). Most individuals do not wish to concern themselves with the inner workings of their healthcare & simply wish to share what they are experiencing and/or feeling. Most people simply want a simple & concise explanation of what is occurring when they go to the Doctor. Fortunately, in 2023 there are a wide array of wonderful tools that can do just this.

First off, if you are feeling lousy, calling your Provider is never a wrong answer. If there is ever any doubt or question to what might be going on with your health, this may be the best first step. However, for individuals with seemingly simple complaints or those who are looking to get in and out of the Doctor quickly, symptom-checker technology might be for you!

Symptom checkers are software based tools in which the patient (or anyone on behalf of the patient) can enter their symptoms and check to see what is likely causing what they are experiencing & why. In addition to this, once you fill out these questions, these applications provide information on how they came to these solutions as well as a recommendation on how to proceed with your care and when to contact a Doctor. These are nothing short of wonderful tools to enhance one’s healthcare experience and speed up the patient visit. Many healthcare institutions have implemented this software into their electronic systems so that the Provider has many of their questions answered before you arrive!

These applications are great for adults, children, men, and women. But the best part? These applications are completely free to use! Yes, that’s free healthcare advice from a system designed by experts in the field!

Accuracy, Ranked

So how accurate are these tools, and which is the best? This is another great question! Below I have compiled conservative percentages of the diagnostic accuracy of each of these tools according to their most recent studies. Additionally, I have ranked the 5 most popular applications in the industry from my personal favorite to least favorite based on usability & accuracy of the technology. Please note that, once again, these programs are completely free to download, access, & use regardless of which Doctor you see!

  1. 1Ada (77% Diagnostic Accuracy)
  2. 2Symptomate (60% Diagnostic Accuracy)
  3. 3Isabel (68% Diagnostic Accuracy)
  4. 4WebMD Symptom Checker (59% Diagnostic Accuracy)
  5. 5Buoy (52% Diagnostic Accuracy)

There is a lot of controversy over whether these AIs can and/or will one day outperform doctors. Nonetheless, these diagnostic accuracy statistics are conservative & surely reflect how great of a tool these applications truly are! One thing to keep in mind while using these tools is that they are risk averse. This means that they will always err on the side of caution with your health and will sometimes recommend more treatment and/or urgent care than necessary.

That said, one of the biggest things patients often fall prey to when doing their own research is having trouble finding quality, evidence-based healthcare information. Yet another advantage to these tools is they can help guide the user to validated, research-based data that is peer-reviewed. This can go a long way in expediting your next visit to the Doctor and impressing your provider with your medical knowledge. In fact, as I previously alluded to, these tools are so powerful and accurate, many healthcare organizations and technology companies are already implementing them into their Provider workflows & patient portals.

Trying Them Yourself

So what is the next step? If you are feeling ill or have an upcoming appointment with your Provider I highly recommend you try these applications out. Below I have provided the links to these applications & sites. These are great ways to both educate yourself & stay ahead of the game with you and your family’s health.

Symptom Checkers & Self-Triage Tools (Ranked)

Ready to be seen?

Answer a few quick questions and we will match you to the right visit with Preston, then show you open times in Cape Girardeau. If you think you are having a medical emergency, call 911.

Sources

  • Barnett ML, Boddupalli D, Nundy S, Bates DW. Comparative Accuracy of Diagnosis by Collective Intelligence of Multiple Physicians vs Individual Physicians. JAMA Netw Open. 2019 Mar 1;2(3):e190096. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.0096. PMID: 30821822; PMCID: PMC6484633.
  • Ceney A, Tolond S, Glowinski A, Marks B, Swift S, et al. (2021) Accuracy of online symptom checkers and the potential impact on service utilisation. PLOS ONE 16(7): e0254088. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254088
  • Gilbert S, Mehl A, Baluch A, et al. How accurate are digital symptom assessment apps for suggesting conditions and urgency advice? A clinical vignettes comparison to GPs. BMJ Open 2020;10:e040269. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-040269
  • Hill, M.G., Sim, M. and Mills, B. (2020), The quality of diagnosis and triage advice provided by free online symptom checkers and apps in Australia. Med. J. Aust., 212: 514-519. https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.50600
  • Kujala S, Hörhammer I. Health Care Professionals’ Experiences of Web-Based Symptom Checkers for Triage: Cross-sectional Survey Study. J Med Internet Res. 2022 May 5;24(5):e33505. doi: 10.2196/33505. PMID: 35511254; PMCID: PMC9121216.
  • Meyer AND, Payne VL, Meeks DW, Rao R, Singh H. Physicians’ Diagnostic Accuracy, Confidence, and Resource Requests: A Vignette Study. JAMA Intern Med. 2013;173(21):1952-1958. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2013.10081

Disclaimer: The purpose of this blog is solely for informational & educational purposes in context of the date of publication in conjunction with the expertise of the author and any collaborators. This blog does not take the place of professional medical advice nor is its author and/or contents responsible for your health or well-being. The content therein is not to serve as a diagnostic or treatment tool. If you or a loved one has any concerns for your health or well-being, you should seek medical care & be evaluated by a licensed healthcare provider in a formal professional setting.

Originally published on Medium in August 2023.

Preston Holifield, DNP, APRN, FNP-C

Written by Preston Holifield, DNP, APRN, FNP-C

Preston is a nationally certified family nurse practitioner who leads Guardian Primary Care in Cape Girardeau, working alongside a Missouri Licensed Collaborating Physician. Meet our team.

Not Sure What Kind of Visit You Need?

Tell us what is going on and we will book the right visit with Preston at a time that works for you.

Guardian Primary Care, 2441 Myra Dr, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703. Visits are by appointment.